Asset Sale vs. Stock Sale
When I first learned that there are two different ways to structure the sale of a business, I rolled my eyes a said, “Of course. Because why not make the M&A process even more complicated? I guess we should be thankful it’s only two?”
Jokes aside, there are important differences between a stock and asset sale. And they both hold value depending on the type of business looking to be acquired. Generally, there is a conflict between the buyer and seller because more often than not, buyers prefer asset sales and sellers prefer stock sales due to various tax implications, potential liabilities, and asset depreciation.
An asset sale is the purchase of individual assets and liabilities. A stock sale is the purchase of the owner’s shares of a corporation.
In order for a stock sale to even be considered, a company cannot be a sole proprietorship, a partnership, or a limited liability company (LLC), due to the lack of stock in these types of entity structures. Only if a business is a regular C-corporation or as a sub-S corporation can the buyer and seller decide whether to structure the deal as an asset sale or a stock sale.
In an asset sale, the seller remains the legal owner of the entity and the buyer purchases the individual assets of the company, such as equipment, fixtures, leaseholds, licenses, goodwill, trade secrets, trade names, telephone numbers, and inventory.
In this type of sale, the seller typically retains the long-term debt obligations, but the seller also keeps the cash on hand—a cash-free, debt-free transaction. Net working capital is generally included: accounts receivable, inventory, prepaid expenses, accounts payable, and accrued expenses.
Buyer advantages of an asset sale:
- Obtain higher valued tax deductions for depreciation and/or amortization
- Expend less time, money, and resources on conducting due diligence due to limited unknown liabilities
- Select which employees wanted and not wanted without impacting company unemployment rates
- Force minority shareholders who do not want to sell their shares to accept the terms
- Decide which assets are going and not going with purchase
Generally a simpler transaction, a stock sale allows for the buyer to purchase the company’s stock, therefore obtaining ownership in the seller’s legal entity. The passing of liabilities and assets is very similar to an asset sale because the titles lie within the business, but separate conveyances of each individual asset are not needed. All assets and liabilities not wanted by the buyer will be distributed or paid off prior to the sale.
Buyer advantages of a stock sale:
- Does not have to bother with costly revaluations and retitles of individual assets
- Assume non-assignable licenses and permits without having to obtain specific consent
- Avoid paying transfer taxes
Know that every M&A transaction and every business is unique, requiring a different and specified sale structure. If you are looking to acquire or sell a business, give us a call at 402-998-5288 and we can advise you through the process.
To read more, check out these sources:
Mariner Capital Advisors’s Asset Sale vs. Stock Sale: What's The Difference?
Corporate Finance Institute’s Asset Purchase vs Stock Purchase
- 11 Years of Omaha Magazine’s “Best of B2B”
- Due Diligence: Preparation is Key
- Your Business as a Machine: Exit Planning Is Not Just for Exiting
- 10 Industries That Will See Post-Pandemic Profits
- Self-Care in a Pandemic
- 5 Most Influential Women in the US
- Advertising Industry Outlook – Adapting Strategies
- How Important Is Due Diligence?
- 6 Best Christmas Movies of All Time
- Construction Industry Outlook – Remodeling & Renovation
- 4 Upcoming Business Trends of 2021
- Industries Booming During COVID-19
- What Are You Thankful For?
- Why it Makes Sense to Carry as a Seller
- Let's Talk About Pets
- What Exactly Are the Benefits of an SBA Loan?
- 2020 Industry Highs and Lows
- What the "Big Buyers" Want
- What’s an earnout, and why does Ryan Reynolds have one?
- M&A Advisor or Business Broker?
- How to Sell a Business in 7 Easy* Steps
- The Firm Advisors: #1 in the World -- Again!
- Documentation is Key During This Time
- Small Business Debt Relief Program
- Work On Your Small Business (While You Aren't Working In It)
- Meet the Listing: Body Shop w/ Towing & Auto Repair
- Superstitions and Deal Killers
- Choosing Your Investments: Stock Market vs. Business Purchase
- Video: Deal Education
- Industry Spotlight: Advertising and Marketing
- Meet the Team: The Firm Advisors Office Tour
- Securing Your Business Against Ransomware
- M&A: What's an M, and what's an A?
- Location, Location, Relocation
- $20M in One Month
- Pet Care: A Recession-Proof Industry
- The Firm Named to BBB Honor Roll
- Firm Family Christmas
- Firmgiving 2019
- Cortney Sells on IBBA's Podcast
- The Firm Makes Inc. 5000
- M&A: The Industry Defying Gravity
- Have You Met Makayla?
- Dr. Lemberg's Pathway to Retirement
- Steven Makes His Mark in M&A
- Hot Off the Press - June 2019 Magazine
- All Good Things Take Time
- The Firm June Magazine Release Celebration
- The Firm Feels Good Doing Good
- Corner Kick Spoils our Swan
- Opportunity of the Week: A Business That Brightens Children’s Futures
- Q&A With Cortney: Stock Sale Versus Asset Sale
- The Ins and Outs of Seller Financing
- Preparing for the Perfect Retirement
- The Firm Is Breaking Industry Records & Poised for Growth in 2019
- Simply the Best
- Competitor Analysis, Opportunities Listed
- Dentist to Dreamer - Hard Work Pays Off!
- Kansas City Tech Company Useagility Sells to First Tek
- 8th Year as Omaha's Best Business Brokerage
- Sellers: Why You Should Finance Your Buyers
- Summer Intern 2017 - Ameya Shelby
- Industry Forecast: Mind the Generational Gap
- 8 Things We Wish Every Business Buyer Knew Before Calling Us
- Selling Your Business: Getting a Proper Business Valuation
- Asset Sales or Stock Sales: Determining the Best for Your Business Transaction
- Why (and How) Business Owners Are Selling in 2017
- The Law of 3's - Choosing the Right Kind of Broker
- A Mutually Beneficial Relationship
- Reaching Out is Key
- Confidential Business Reviews
- A Change of Pace to Business Ownership
- Confidentiality is at the Core of Business
- Moving into the Boardroom
- Buying a Business vs. Starting Your Own
- Bringing Buyers and Sellers Together is Just the Beginning
- Client Interfacing in the Digital Age
- Four Questions Every Buyer Should Ask
- The Firm Outpaces Transaction Totals from Previous Two Years
- Faces of Omaha 2016: Face of Business Brokerages
- The Firm Business Brokerage Set to Double Sales within Seller's Market - MBJ 2014